In short: You can't relax because, for your body, rest doesn't read as safety — it reads as exposure. If your worth was earned by doing, stillness is the moment the performance stops and you might get caught. So the body keeps guard — jaw, shoulders, breath — precisely when the diary finally clears. The way back isn't trying harder to relax. It's giving your body small, physical evidence that it's safe to put the guard down.
She'd been protecting that Saturday for weeks. No plans. No visitors. Nothing in the diary.
By ten in the morning she'd emptied the dishwasher, answered three emails that could have waited until Monday, and wiped down a kitchen counter that was already clean. She made a cup of tea, sat down, and was back on her feet within four minutes.
When she told me about it, she said the sentence I've heard hundreds of times in twenty years of this work: "I finally had the time. And I couldn't do it. What's wrong with me?"
Nothing is wrong with her. And if that morning sounds like yours — nothing is wrong with you either. But something very specific is happening in you, and once you see it, the whole thing stops being a mystery.
Why can't I relax?
Here's the direct answer.
You can't relax because, somewhere along the way, your worth got tied to doing. And if your worth is earned by doing, then stillness isn't rest — it's exposure. The moment you stop, the evidence stops. So your body treats an empty Saturday the way it would treat a threat.
Psychologists call this hypervigilance. I call it the guard that never clocks off. Somewhere — usually long before the career, usually in a house where you learned to be helpful, easy, on top of things — a part of you took up a post. Watch the room. Stay useful. Don't get caught doing nothing. That guard has been on duty for decades. You don't hand it one free weekend and expect it to take the day off.
And here's the twist that catches everyone: to the guard, stillness is when you're most catchable. Busy, you're covered. Producing, you're safe. Sitting on the sofa with nothing to show for yourself? That's when the old alarm goes: someone's going to notice.
In 5,600+ live sessions I have never once met a woman who couldn't relax because she was lazy or bad at self-care. Every single time, her body was doing exactly what it was trained to do. Bessel van der Kolk spent decades showing that the body stores what never got processed. Your restlessness on a quiet afternoon isn't a character flaw. It's storage.
"I'm just so tired."
"I tend to get through things rather than fully experience them."
If those are your sentences too — keep reading.
Why can't I relax my shoulders?
Because your shoulders are doing a job.
You've noticed them up around your ears. You've been told — by the yoga teacher, the massage therapist, your own reflection — to drop them. And they drop, for about eight seconds. Then they creep straight back up, like they never got the memo.
They got the memo. They're ignoring it, because from your body's point of view, raised shoulders are not tension — they're armour. Braced for the next thing. Carrying what you never put down. You've held that shape for so long it's become your default posture, which is exactly why you can't feel it anymore. You only notice you were "super tensed up" in the rare moments the tension briefly leaves.
"Relax your shoulders" fails because it's an instruction to abandon a post while the guard still believes the threat is real. You can't order armour off. You can only show the body, in small doses, that it's not needed right now. More on how in a moment.
Enjoying this? Get my latest sent straight to your inbox.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Why can't I relax my jaw?
The jaw is where everything you didn't say went to live.
Every swallowed no. Every "of course, no problem" your mouth said before your brain caught up. Every time you bit down on the honest sentence because it wasn't worth the fallout. That's decades of held-back words, and they didn't evaporate. They clenched.
Maybe you wake with it aching. Maybe the dentist has mentioned grinding. Maybe you've just realised, reading this, that your teeth are touching right now and your tongue is pressed to the roof of your mouth.
Your body is saying what your mouth won't. The jaw doesn't unclench through willpower for the same reason the shoulders don't drop — it's not a habit, it's a holding. And holdings release when they get evidence, not instructions.
Why can I only relax when I'm alone?
Because the Performing Self is only off-duty when you're alone.
You know her. The version of you that goes to work, answers the messages, smiles in the meetings, remembers everyone's birthdays. She's brilliant. She got you here. And she runs on one condition: while anyone is watching, the performance is on. Even with people you love. Even at dinner with friends. Part of you is monitoring — how am I coming across, does anyone need anything, is everyone okay — and monitoring is work.
So the only genuine exhale happens when the front door closes and there's no one left to perform for. That's not introversion. That's not "just being private." That's the cost of the performance, measured in who you can breathe around.
But notice something, gently: is what you do alone actually rest? Or is it collapse — the scrolling, the numbing, the staring at a series you're not really watching? There's a difference between relaxing and falling over. Most of the women I work with haven't relaxed in years. They've alternated between performing and collapsing, and called the collapse "me time."
Real rest — present, warm, actually in the moment — is a different thing entirely. I went deeper on what being present actually feels like in the body in [this episode on the present moment](/blog/podcast-ep32-present-moment).
Why am I always tired but can't rest?
This is the one that sounds like a contradiction and isn't.
You're exhausted — tired in a way sleep doesn't fix — and yet the moment you lie down, you're wired. Mind racing, body humming, three a.m. staring at the ceiling. The research world calls it being "tired but wired." In body terms it's simple: one foot flat on the accelerator, one foot flat on the brake. The body is spent. The guard is still on shift. Exhaustion and alertness aren't opposites — they're what it feels like to run both at once, for years.
That's also why this kind of tiredness has layers to it — I've broken down [the four layers of exhaustion here](/blog/blog-3-four-layers-exhaustion), because the deepest layer is never about workload.
And it matters more than comfort. The ACE Study followed more than 17,000 people and found that what the body carries from early adversity doesn't stay in childhood — it shows up decades later as adult illness. The migraines, the back that "goes out," the gut that never settles. Your body isn't being dramatic. It's keeping count.
What actually lets the guard clock off?
Not trying harder to relax. You've tried that. Effort is the guard's native language — "relax properly" just becomes one more performance to nail.
The guard stands down on evidence, not instructions. Small, physical, boring, repeated evidence. Here's some you can gather in the next five minutes:
1. Find the guard first. Right now, without changing anything — where is it? Jaw? Shoulders? A low clench in the gut? Don't fix it. Just locate it. Scientists call this sense of the inner body interoception; I call it answering a phone that's been ringing for years. Noticing is the first evidence.
2. Read your breath. One hand on your ribs. Is your inhale short and your exhale long? For most over-givers it is — you are literally giving out more than you take in, with every breath, all day. Just watch it for five breaths. Then, on one exhale only, let the shoulders fall. Not hold them down — fall. If they creep back, fine. You're not winning a war. You're leaving evidence.
3. Give the jaw one honest exhale. Let your lips part slightly, teeth apart, tongue soft. Breathe out through the mouth once, slowly, and let it be a bit loud. That's one swallowed sentence leaving.
4. Give the guard a shift-end. Set a timer for two minutes and do nothing. Not meditation-nothing. Actual nothing. When the itch to get up comes — and it will, around minute one — that itch is the whole pattern, live. Feel it, and stay seated anyway. Two minutes of the guard being off-duty, with nothing bad happening, is worth more to your body than an hour of reading about rest.
You are allowed to rest without earning it first. Your body just doesn't believe that yet — and it won't believe words. It will believe two minutes. Then five. It's a muscle, and it trains like one.
If you want to see the shape of the pattern that trained your guard in the first place — where it came from, and what it's costing you — take the quiz here. It takes a few minutes and most people say the results read like someone's been watching them.
The guard was never your enemy. It kept a small version of you safe in a world that asked her to earn her place. It just never got told the shift is over.
You get to tell it. Not with your mind — it's heard your mind for years. With your shoulders, your jaw, your breath.
Two minutes at a time.
Questions People Ask
Why can't I relax even on holiday?
Because you took your nervous system with you. A new location doesn't stand the guard down — for the first few days your body is still scanning, planning, half-braced, which is why many people only start to unwind at the exact point the holiday ends. Rest isn't a place, it's a state your body has to learn is safe. That learning happens in small daily doses at home, not in one week a year.
Why do I feel guilty when I rest?
Because somewhere you learned that your worth is earned by doing, so rest registers as theft — taking something you haven't paid for. The guilt isn't proof you're lazy; it's the old programme protesting. It usually spikes hardest at the start of genuine rest, then fades if you stay. Feeling guilty and resting anyway, in small doses, is exactly how the pattern retrains.
How do I train my body to relax?
Through evidence, not effort. Locate the tension without fixing it, lengthen one exhale and let the shoulders fall on it, soften the jaw with lips slightly parted, and practise two minutes of doing nothing daily. Repetition matters more than duration — each small dose where nothing bad happens teaches your body that stillness is safe. Understanding relaxation changes nothing; experiencing it, briefly and often, changes the pattern.